Comments on: 126. Broken Social Scene – 7/4 (Shoreline) http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/ I make the lists, you shoot them down. Quid Pro Quo. Fri, 19 Mar 2010 16:26:11 -0700 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.5 hourly 1 By: Drew http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/comment-page-1/#comment-212 Drew Wed, 02 Dec 2009 16:58:08 +0000 http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/#comment-212 Dear Adam, Two definites there in Arcade Fire and The Hold Steady. Even with the lack of material, Arcade Fire has to be a top ten band of the '00s. And The Hold Steady is a Top Ten band of 1975. Dear Adam,

Two definites there in Arcade Fire and The Hold Steady. Even with the lack of material, Arcade Fire has to be a top ten band of the ’00s. And The Hold Steady is a Top Ten band of 1975.

]]> By: Adam http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/comment-page-1/#comment-208 Adam Tue, 01 Dec 2009 16:34:21 +0000 http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/#comment-208 Arcade Fire has to count. Only two full albums and an EP, but that's still more than BSS as a full band (not counting Feel Good Lost). I'd throw The Decemberists out there, but I don't know if I consider them "great." The Hold Steady gets the nod fo' sho'. Arcade Fire has to count. Only two full albums and an EP, but that’s still more than BSS as a full band (not counting Feel Good Lost). I’d throw The Decemberists out there, but I don’t know if I consider them “great.” The Hold Steady gets the nod fo’ sho’.

]]> By: Drew http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/comment-page-1/#comment-184 Drew Wed, 25 Nov 2009 00:24:44 +0000 http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/#comment-184 Dear Becky, You are correct. Postal Service made one album that I would consider Fantastic. And I would count them as a band, because there were two permanent members but then also a bunch of guests (specifically Jenny Lewis.) Also, I DO love when you contribute to the blog...haha. Dear Sean You should listen to more BSS if you liked this. They are certainly one of the top ten bands of the decade, and they have been consistently great. Check out their album You Forget it in People. Or, SPOILERS, stay tuned to the list. Mae Shi put out a great album, but they needed to put out another before imploding. Sadly, Run to Your Grave won't make it on the list. I know it must pain you that the Stripes just missed the decade cut, too. Who else has something? c'monnnnnn Dear Becky,

You are correct. Postal Service made one album that I would consider Fantastic. And I would count them as a band, because there were two permanent members but then also a bunch of guests (specifically Jenny Lewis.) Also, I DO love when you contribute to the blog…haha.

Dear Sean

You should listen to more BSS if you liked this. They are certainly one of the top ten bands of the decade, and they have been consistently great. Check out their album You Forget it in People. Or, SPOILERS, stay tuned to the list.

Mae Shi put out a great album, but they needed to put out another before imploding. Sadly, Run to Your Grave won’t make it on the list. I know it must pain you that the Stripes just missed the decade cut, too.

Who else has something? c’monnnnnn

]]> By: Sean http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/comment-page-1/#comment-183 Sean Tue, 24 Nov 2009 22:44:11 +0000 http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/#comment-183 I like this song, especially the horns. Didn't really know anything about Broken Social Scene before. As for the side-discussion, what about the Mae Shi? I dunno if it counts since the name (and part of the band) is still there. But if it's all in the name then you might have to count Santigold.... I like this song, especially the horns. Didn’t really know anything about Broken Social Scene before.

As for the side-discussion, what about the Mae Shi? I dunno if it counts since the name (and part of the band) is still there.

But if it’s all in the name then you might have to count Santigold….

]]> By: Becky http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/comment-page-1/#comment-182 Becky Tue, 24 Nov 2009 21:11:43 +0000 http://thelistomania.com/2009/11/126-broken-social-scene-74-shoreline/#comment-182 i dont konw if this counts. but postal service? i like them, but i'm sure you are much more opinionated than 'like vs dislike' and also, is it really a 'band'? you know that you love when i contribute to this wall. i dont konw if this counts. but postal service?

i like them, but i’m sure you are much more opinionated than ‘like vs dislike’ and also, is it really a ‘band’?

you know that you love when i contribute to this wall.

]]>